Remittances and land change: A systematic review

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articleResearchpeer review

Authors

  • Elizabeth A. Mack
  • Laura Aileen Sauls
  • Brad D. Jokisch
  • Kerstin Nolte
  • Birgit Schmook
  • Yifan He
  • Claudia Radel
  • Ginger R.H. Allington
  • Lisa C. Kelley
  • Christian Kelly Scott
  • Stephen Leisz
  • Guangqing Chi
  • Lira Sagynbekova
  • Nicholas Cuba
  • Geoffrey M. Henebry

External Research Organisations

  • Michigan State University (MSU)
  • George Mason University
  • Ohio University
  • El Colegio de la Frontera Sur (Econsur)
  • University of California at Santa Barbara
  • Utah State University
  • Cornell University
  • University of Colorado Denver
  • Mississippi State University
  • Colorado State University
  • Pennsylvania State University
  • Auburn University (AU)
View graph of relations

Details

Original languageEnglish
Article number106251
JournalWorld development
Volume168
Early online date12 Apr 2023
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2023

Abstract

Remittances—funds sent by migrants to family and friends back home—are an important source of global monetary flows, and they have implications for the maintenance and transformation of land systems. A number of published reviews have synthesized work on a variety of aspects of remittances (e.g., rural livelihoods, disasters, and economic development). To our knowledge, there are no reviews of work investigating the linkages between remittances and land change, broadly understood. This knowledge gap is important to address because researchers have recognized that remittances flows are a mechanism that helps to explain how migration can affect land change. Thus, understanding the specific roles remittances play in land system changes should help to clarify the multiple processes associated with migration and their independent and interactive effects. To address the state of knowledge about the connection between remittances and land systems, this paper conducts a systematic review. Our review of 51 journal articles finds that the linkages uncovered were commonly subtle and/or indirect. Very few studies looked at the direct connections between receipt of remittances and quantitative changes in land. Most commonly, the relationship between remittances and land change was found to occur through pathways from labor migration to household income to agricultural development and productivity. We find four non-exclusive pathways through which households spend remittances with consequent changes to land systems: (1) agricultural crops and livestock, (2) agricultural labor and technologies, (3) land purchases, and (4) non-agricultural purchases and consumables. In the papers reviewed, these expenditures are linked to various land system change outcomes, including land use change, soil degradation, pasture degradation, afforestation/deforestation/degradation, agricultural intensification/extensification/diversification, and no impact. These findings suggest four avenues for future research. One avenue is the use of the theoretical lens of telecoupling to understand how remittances may produce wider-scale changes in land systems. A second avenue is further examination of the impacts of shocks and disturbances to remittance flows on land change both in migrant sending and in remittance receiving areas. A third avenue is scholarship that examines the extent that household uses of remittances have a “ripple effect” on land uses in nearby interlinked systems. A fourth avenue for future work is the use of spatially explicit modeling that leverages land cover and land use data based on imagery and other geospatial information.

Keywords

    Land change, Land systems, Land use, Migration, Remittances, Rural

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Sustainable Development Goals

Cite this

Remittances and land change: A systematic review. / Mack, Elizabeth A.; Sauls, Laura Aileen; Jokisch, Brad D. et al.
In: World development, Vol. 168, 106251, 08.2023.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articleResearchpeer review

Mack, EA, Sauls, LA, Jokisch, BD, Nolte, K, Schmook, B, He, Y, Radel, C, Allington, GRH, Kelley, LC, Scott, CK, Leisz, S, Chi, G, Sagynbekova, L, Cuba, N & Henebry, GM 2023, 'Remittances and land change: A systematic review', World development, vol. 168, 106251. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2023.106251
Mack, E. A., Sauls, L. A., Jokisch, B. D., Nolte, K., Schmook, B., He, Y., Radel, C., Allington, G. R. H., Kelley, L. C., Scott, C. K., Leisz, S., Chi, G., Sagynbekova, L., Cuba, N., & Henebry, G. M. (2023). Remittances and land change: A systematic review. World development, 168, Article 106251. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.worlddev.2023.106251
Mack EA, Sauls LA, Jokisch BD, Nolte K, Schmook B, He Y et al. Remittances and land change: A systematic review. World development. 2023 Aug;168:106251. Epub 2023 Apr 12. doi: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2023.106251
Mack, Elizabeth A. ; Sauls, Laura Aileen ; Jokisch, Brad D. et al. / Remittances and land change : A systematic review. In: World development. 2023 ; Vol. 168.
Download
@article{e4c48f1a804f46cd96706e3eced33320,
title = "Remittances and land change: A systematic review",
abstract = "Remittances—funds sent by migrants to family and friends back home—are an important source of global monetary flows, and they have implications for the maintenance and transformation of land systems. A number of published reviews have synthesized work on a variety of aspects of remittances (e.g., rural livelihoods, disasters, and economic development). To our knowledge, there are no reviews of work investigating the linkages between remittances and land change, broadly understood. This knowledge gap is important to address because researchers have recognized that remittances flows are a mechanism that helps to explain how migration can affect land change. Thus, understanding the specific roles remittances play in land system changes should help to clarify the multiple processes associated with migration and their independent and interactive effects. To address the state of knowledge about the connection between remittances and land systems, this paper conducts a systematic review. Our review of 51 journal articles finds that the linkages uncovered were commonly subtle and/or indirect. Very few studies looked at the direct connections between receipt of remittances and quantitative changes in land. Most commonly, the relationship between remittances and land change was found to occur through pathways from labor migration to household income to agricultural development and productivity. We find four non-exclusive pathways through which households spend remittances with consequent changes to land systems: (1) agricultural crops and livestock, (2) agricultural labor and technologies, (3) land purchases, and (4) non-agricultural purchases and consumables. In the papers reviewed, these expenditures are linked to various land system change outcomes, including land use change, soil degradation, pasture degradation, afforestation/deforestation/degradation, agricultural intensification/extensification/diversification, and no impact. These findings suggest four avenues for future research. One avenue is the use of the theoretical lens of telecoupling to understand how remittances may produce wider-scale changes in land systems. A second avenue is further examination of the impacts of shocks and disturbances to remittance flows on land change both in migrant sending and in remittance receiving areas. A third avenue is scholarship that examines the extent that household uses of remittances have a “ripple effect” on land uses in nearby interlinked systems. A fourth avenue for future work is the use of spatially explicit modeling that leverages land cover and land use data based on imagery and other geospatial information.",
keywords = "Land change, Land systems, Land use, Migration, Remittances, Rural",
author = "Mack, {Elizabeth A.} and Sauls, {Laura Aileen} and Jokisch, {Brad D.} and Kerstin Nolte and Birgit Schmook and Yifan He and Claudia Radel and Allington, {Ginger R.H.} and Kelley, {Lisa C.} and Scott, {Christian Kelly} and Stephen Leisz and Guangqing Chi and Lira Sagynbekova and Nicholas Cuba and Henebry, {Geoffrey M.}",
note = "Funding Information: We acknowledge the Global Land Project (https://glp.earth) for facilitating our Working Group on Remittance Dynamics and Land Change (https://glp.earth/how-we-work/working-groups/remittance-dynamics-and-land-change). In addition, we acknowledge support from the following sources that helped contribute to this review: NASA LCLUC projects 80NSSC20K0411 and 80NSSC21K1431. The following outlines each author's contribution to the manuscript: Conceptualization, EAM, GMH; methodology, EAM, GMH, LAS, BS, CAR; formal analysis, LAS, BDJ, EAM, GMH, GRHA, BS, YH, CAR, GC, CKS, KN, NC, SL, LK; writing, LAS, BDJ, EAM, GMH, GRHA, BS, YH, CAR, GC, CKS, KN, NC, SL, LK; visualization, EAM, LAS; funding acquisition, GMH; page charges, GMH and NC. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript. ",
year = "2023",
month = aug,
doi = "10.1016/j.worlddev.2023.106251",
language = "English",
volume = "168",
journal = "World development",
issn = "0305-750X",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

Download

TY - JOUR

T1 - Remittances and land change

T2 - A systematic review

AU - Mack, Elizabeth A.

AU - Sauls, Laura Aileen

AU - Jokisch, Brad D.

AU - Nolte, Kerstin

AU - Schmook, Birgit

AU - He, Yifan

AU - Radel, Claudia

AU - Allington, Ginger R.H.

AU - Kelley, Lisa C.

AU - Scott, Christian Kelly

AU - Leisz, Stephen

AU - Chi, Guangqing

AU - Sagynbekova, Lira

AU - Cuba, Nicholas

AU - Henebry, Geoffrey M.

N1 - Funding Information: We acknowledge the Global Land Project (https://glp.earth) for facilitating our Working Group on Remittance Dynamics and Land Change (https://glp.earth/how-we-work/working-groups/remittance-dynamics-and-land-change). In addition, we acknowledge support from the following sources that helped contribute to this review: NASA LCLUC projects 80NSSC20K0411 and 80NSSC21K1431. The following outlines each author's contribution to the manuscript: Conceptualization, EAM, GMH; methodology, EAM, GMH, LAS, BS, CAR; formal analysis, LAS, BDJ, EAM, GMH, GRHA, BS, YH, CAR, GC, CKS, KN, NC, SL, LK; writing, LAS, BDJ, EAM, GMH, GRHA, BS, YH, CAR, GC, CKS, KN, NC, SL, LK; visualization, EAM, LAS; funding acquisition, GMH; page charges, GMH and NC. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

PY - 2023/8

Y1 - 2023/8

N2 - Remittances—funds sent by migrants to family and friends back home—are an important source of global monetary flows, and they have implications for the maintenance and transformation of land systems. A number of published reviews have synthesized work on a variety of aspects of remittances (e.g., rural livelihoods, disasters, and economic development). To our knowledge, there are no reviews of work investigating the linkages between remittances and land change, broadly understood. This knowledge gap is important to address because researchers have recognized that remittances flows are a mechanism that helps to explain how migration can affect land change. Thus, understanding the specific roles remittances play in land system changes should help to clarify the multiple processes associated with migration and their independent and interactive effects. To address the state of knowledge about the connection between remittances and land systems, this paper conducts a systematic review. Our review of 51 journal articles finds that the linkages uncovered were commonly subtle and/or indirect. Very few studies looked at the direct connections between receipt of remittances and quantitative changes in land. Most commonly, the relationship between remittances and land change was found to occur through pathways from labor migration to household income to agricultural development and productivity. We find four non-exclusive pathways through which households spend remittances with consequent changes to land systems: (1) agricultural crops and livestock, (2) agricultural labor and technologies, (3) land purchases, and (4) non-agricultural purchases and consumables. In the papers reviewed, these expenditures are linked to various land system change outcomes, including land use change, soil degradation, pasture degradation, afforestation/deforestation/degradation, agricultural intensification/extensification/diversification, and no impact. These findings suggest four avenues for future research. One avenue is the use of the theoretical lens of telecoupling to understand how remittances may produce wider-scale changes in land systems. A second avenue is further examination of the impacts of shocks and disturbances to remittance flows on land change both in migrant sending and in remittance receiving areas. A third avenue is scholarship that examines the extent that household uses of remittances have a “ripple effect” on land uses in nearby interlinked systems. A fourth avenue for future work is the use of spatially explicit modeling that leverages land cover and land use data based on imagery and other geospatial information.

AB - Remittances—funds sent by migrants to family and friends back home—are an important source of global monetary flows, and they have implications for the maintenance and transformation of land systems. A number of published reviews have synthesized work on a variety of aspects of remittances (e.g., rural livelihoods, disasters, and economic development). To our knowledge, there are no reviews of work investigating the linkages between remittances and land change, broadly understood. This knowledge gap is important to address because researchers have recognized that remittances flows are a mechanism that helps to explain how migration can affect land change. Thus, understanding the specific roles remittances play in land system changes should help to clarify the multiple processes associated with migration and their independent and interactive effects. To address the state of knowledge about the connection between remittances and land systems, this paper conducts a systematic review. Our review of 51 journal articles finds that the linkages uncovered were commonly subtle and/or indirect. Very few studies looked at the direct connections between receipt of remittances and quantitative changes in land. Most commonly, the relationship between remittances and land change was found to occur through pathways from labor migration to household income to agricultural development and productivity. We find four non-exclusive pathways through which households spend remittances with consequent changes to land systems: (1) agricultural crops and livestock, (2) agricultural labor and technologies, (3) land purchases, and (4) non-agricultural purchases and consumables. In the papers reviewed, these expenditures are linked to various land system change outcomes, including land use change, soil degradation, pasture degradation, afforestation/deforestation/degradation, agricultural intensification/extensification/diversification, and no impact. These findings suggest four avenues for future research. One avenue is the use of the theoretical lens of telecoupling to understand how remittances may produce wider-scale changes in land systems. A second avenue is further examination of the impacts of shocks and disturbances to remittance flows on land change both in migrant sending and in remittance receiving areas. A third avenue is scholarship that examines the extent that household uses of remittances have a “ripple effect” on land uses in nearby interlinked systems. A fourth avenue for future work is the use of spatially explicit modeling that leverages land cover and land use data based on imagery and other geospatial information.

KW - Land change

KW - Land systems

KW - Land use

KW - Migration

KW - Remittances

KW - Rural

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85152121938&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.worlddev.2023.106251

DO - 10.1016/j.worlddev.2023.106251

M3 - Review article

AN - SCOPUS:85152121938

VL - 168

JO - World development

JF - World development

SN - 0305-750X

M1 - 106251

ER -

By the same author(s)