Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower

Research output: Chapter in book/report/conference proceedingContribution to book/anthologyResearch

View graph of relations

Details

Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationExperimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures
Subtitle of host publicationEVACES 2025
EditorsÁlvaro Cunha, Elsa Caetano
Chapter25
Pages272-280
Number of pages9
Volume1
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2025

Publication series

NameExperimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures
Volume674
ISSN (Print)2366-2557
ISSN (electronic)2366-2565

Abstract

Many tower structures, such as wind turbines, are continuously monitored to detect damage at an early stage. Due to their symmetrical cross-section, tower structures often exhibit closely spaced modes, making system identification challenging and often subject to significant uncertainties. Other damage-sensitive features (DSFs), such as autocovariance functions (ACFs), are currently being researched as an alternative to modal parameters. ACFs can be quickly and easily estimated from the acceleration measurement data without the need for system identification. Since ACFs have the same mathematical form as a free decay of the system under stationary random excitation, they carry information about the natural frequencies and mode shapes. In this paper, ACFs are used as DSFs in combination with a whitening transformation for data normalisation. This method does not require measurements of environmental conditions (ECs). A disadvantage of the investigated method is the tendency to result in false negatives when the structure is weakly excited. To address this issue, an extension of the method that reduces the excitation dependence of the DSFs is proposed in this contribution. While the method’s ability to detect and localise damage has been demonstrated using simulated and experimental data, it has not yet been systematically tested for different damage scenarios. Therefore, in this paper, the method is applied to an ambient-excited lattice tower featuring reversible damage mechanisms. Six damage scenarios are investigated here, differing in location and severity. With the extended method, damage can be reliably detected in five of the six investigated damage scenarios, showing the applicability of ACFs for damage detection. However, challenges persist, notably false positives arising from unrepresented ECs in the training data. This finding underscores the importance of encompassing a wide range of ECs in the training phase to mitigate such false alarms. These results underline that physical interpretability and data normalisation play an important role in selecting suitable DSFs. Damage localisation using the proposed method is compared to the established mode shape curvature method. Both methods are only able to correctly localise three of the investigated damages. However, the results differ significantly when the damage cannot be localised correctly.

Keywords

    Autocovariance Function, Damage Detection, Damage Localisation, Damage-Sensitive Feature, Structural Health Monitoring

ASJC Scopus subject areas

Cite this

Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower. / Thurn, Jonathan; Kullaa, Jyrki; Jonscher, Clemens et al.
Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures : EVACES 2025. ed. / Álvaro Cunha; Elsa Caetano. Vol. 1 2025. p. 272-280 (Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures; Vol. 674).

Research output: Chapter in book/report/conference proceedingContribution to book/anthologyResearch

Thurn, J, Kullaa, J, Jonscher, C & Rolfes, R 2025, Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower. in Á Cunha & E Caetano (eds), Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures : EVACES 2025. vol. 1, Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures, vol. 674, pp. 272-280. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-96110-6_25
Thurn, J., Kullaa, J., Jonscher, C., & Rolfes, R. (2025). Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower. In Á. Cunha, & E. Caetano (Eds.), Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures : EVACES 2025 (Vol. 1, pp. 272-280). (Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures; Vol. 674). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-96110-6_25
Thurn J, Kullaa J, Jonscher C, Rolfes R. Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower. In Cunha Á, Caetano E, editors, Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures : EVACES 2025. Vol. 1. 2025. p. 272-280. (Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures). doi: 10.1007/978-3-031-96110-6_25
Thurn, Jonathan ; Kullaa, Jyrki ; Jonscher, Clemens et al. / Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower. Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures : EVACES 2025. editor / Álvaro Cunha ; Elsa Caetano. Vol. 1 2025. pp. 272-280 (Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures).
Download
@inbook{04821b41908f47fe8e84af2d0ba8859b,
title = "Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower",
abstract = "Many tower structures, such as wind turbines, are continuously monitored to detect damage at an early stage. Due to their symmetrical cross-section, tower structures often exhibit closely spaced modes, making system identification challenging and often subject to significant uncertainties. Other damage-sensitive features (DSFs), such as autocovariance functions (ACFs), are currently being researched as an alternative to modal parameters. ACFs can be quickly and easily estimated from the acceleration measurement data without the need for system identification. Since ACFs have the same mathematical form as a free decay of the system under stationary random excitation, they carry information about the natural frequencies and mode shapes. In this paper, ACFs are used as DSFs in combination with a whitening transformation for data normalisation. This method does not require measurements of environmental conditions (ECs). A disadvantage of the investigated method is the tendency to result in false negatives when the structure is weakly excited. To address this issue, an extension of the method that reduces the excitation dependence of the DSFs is proposed in this contribution. While the method{\textquoteright}s ability to detect and localise damage has been demonstrated using simulated and experimental data, it has not yet been systematically tested for different damage scenarios. Therefore, in this paper, the method is applied to an ambient-excited lattice tower featuring reversible damage mechanisms. Six damage scenarios are investigated here, differing in location and severity. With the extended method, damage can be reliably detected in five of the six investigated damage scenarios, showing the applicability of ACFs for damage detection. However, challenges persist, notably false positives arising from unrepresented ECs in the training data. This finding underscores the importance of encompassing a wide range of ECs in the training phase to mitigate such false alarms. These results underline that physical interpretability and data normalisation play an important role in selecting suitable DSFs. Damage localisation using the proposed method is compared to the established mode shape curvature method. Both methods are only able to correctly localise three of the investigated damages. However, the results differ significantly when the damage cannot be localised correctly.",
keywords = "Autocovariance Function, Damage Detection, Damage Localisation, Damage-Sensitive Feature, Structural Health Monitoring",
author = "Jonathan Thurn and Jyrki Kullaa and Clemens Jonscher and Raimund Rolfes",
note = "Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2025.",
year = "2025",
month = oct,
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/978-3-031-96110-6_25",
language = "English",
isbn = "9783031961090",
volume = "1",
series = "Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures",
pages = "272--280",
editor = "{\'A}lvaro Cunha and Elsa Caetano",
booktitle = "Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures",

}

Download

TY - CHAP

T1 - Autocovariance Functions as Damage Sensitive Features: Case Study of a Lattice Tower

AU - Thurn, Jonathan

AU - Kullaa, Jyrki

AU - Jonscher, Clemens

AU - Rolfes, Raimund

N1 - Publisher Copyright: © The Author(s), under exclusive license to Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2025.

PY - 2025/10/1

Y1 - 2025/10/1

N2 - Many tower structures, such as wind turbines, are continuously monitored to detect damage at an early stage. Due to their symmetrical cross-section, tower structures often exhibit closely spaced modes, making system identification challenging and often subject to significant uncertainties. Other damage-sensitive features (DSFs), such as autocovariance functions (ACFs), are currently being researched as an alternative to modal parameters. ACFs can be quickly and easily estimated from the acceleration measurement data without the need for system identification. Since ACFs have the same mathematical form as a free decay of the system under stationary random excitation, they carry information about the natural frequencies and mode shapes. In this paper, ACFs are used as DSFs in combination with a whitening transformation for data normalisation. This method does not require measurements of environmental conditions (ECs). A disadvantage of the investigated method is the tendency to result in false negatives when the structure is weakly excited. To address this issue, an extension of the method that reduces the excitation dependence of the DSFs is proposed in this contribution. While the method’s ability to detect and localise damage has been demonstrated using simulated and experimental data, it has not yet been systematically tested for different damage scenarios. Therefore, in this paper, the method is applied to an ambient-excited lattice tower featuring reversible damage mechanisms. Six damage scenarios are investigated here, differing in location and severity. With the extended method, damage can be reliably detected in five of the six investigated damage scenarios, showing the applicability of ACFs for damage detection. However, challenges persist, notably false positives arising from unrepresented ECs in the training data. This finding underscores the importance of encompassing a wide range of ECs in the training phase to mitigate such false alarms. These results underline that physical interpretability and data normalisation play an important role in selecting suitable DSFs. Damage localisation using the proposed method is compared to the established mode shape curvature method. Both methods are only able to correctly localise three of the investigated damages. However, the results differ significantly when the damage cannot be localised correctly.

AB - Many tower structures, such as wind turbines, are continuously monitored to detect damage at an early stage. Due to their symmetrical cross-section, tower structures often exhibit closely spaced modes, making system identification challenging and often subject to significant uncertainties. Other damage-sensitive features (DSFs), such as autocovariance functions (ACFs), are currently being researched as an alternative to modal parameters. ACFs can be quickly and easily estimated from the acceleration measurement data without the need for system identification. Since ACFs have the same mathematical form as a free decay of the system under stationary random excitation, they carry information about the natural frequencies and mode shapes. In this paper, ACFs are used as DSFs in combination with a whitening transformation for data normalisation. This method does not require measurements of environmental conditions (ECs). A disadvantage of the investigated method is the tendency to result in false negatives when the structure is weakly excited. To address this issue, an extension of the method that reduces the excitation dependence of the DSFs is proposed in this contribution. While the method’s ability to detect and localise damage has been demonstrated using simulated and experimental data, it has not yet been systematically tested for different damage scenarios. Therefore, in this paper, the method is applied to an ambient-excited lattice tower featuring reversible damage mechanisms. Six damage scenarios are investigated here, differing in location and severity. With the extended method, damage can be reliably detected in five of the six investigated damage scenarios, showing the applicability of ACFs for damage detection. However, challenges persist, notably false positives arising from unrepresented ECs in the training data. This finding underscores the importance of encompassing a wide range of ECs in the training phase to mitigate such false alarms. These results underline that physical interpretability and data normalisation play an important role in selecting suitable DSFs. Damage localisation using the proposed method is compared to the established mode shape curvature method. Both methods are only able to correctly localise three of the investigated damages. However, the results differ significantly when the damage cannot be localised correctly.

KW - Autocovariance Function

KW - Damage Detection

KW - Damage Localisation

KW - Damage-Sensitive Feature

KW - Structural Health Monitoring

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=105018043061&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/978-3-031-96110-6_25

DO - 10.1007/978-3-031-96110-6_25

M3 - Contribution to book/anthology

SN - 9783031961090

VL - 1

T3 - Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures

SP - 272

EP - 280

BT - Experimental Vibration Analysis for Civil Engineering Structures

A2 - Cunha, Álvaro

A2 - Caetano, Elsa

ER -

By the same author(s)